Andrew Luck

Discussion in 'Tennessee Titans and NFL Talk' started by MariGOATa, Sep 15, 2017.

  1. MariGOATa

    MariGOATa Starter

    1,385
    276
    164
    Once again, like I stated every QB metric has its cons, but you have to account for other stats it isnt only winning percentage. But in my opinion when evaulating best top 5 QBs of all time, I look at their wins and losses first than the stats overall, and I make my own decision pure on those. If it was just pure stats alone that suggests that Manning is hands down the greatest of all time, wich isnt the case.
  2. Deuce Wayne

    Deuce Wayne Damnit, I cant find my driving moccasins anywhere!

    32,485
    7,375
    1,259
  3. Zack3000

    Zack3000 Special Teams Standout

    342
    94
    54
    This thread is ridiculous. 24 pages of a guy trying to convince Titan fans that Andrew luck is good...
  4. 10ACTyrant

    10ACTyrant Starter

    3,151
    404
    109
    how many touchdowns? Brett favre threw a ton of interceptions. Did he suck?
    titantrusince82 and MariGOATa high five this.
  5. 10ACTyrant

    10ACTyrant Starter

    3,151
    404
    109
    Also, that meme isn't even right, or it's just really old. Cutler has 60 INTs since Luck came in the league. And I'll answer the touchdown question. Cutler has 92 touchdowns to Luck's 132.

    So, good meme bro.
  6. Deuce Wayne

    Deuce Wayne Damnit, I cant find my driving moccasins anywhere!

    32,485
    7,375
    1,259
    Did you really just compare Brett Favre to Andrew Luck?

    3 consecutive MVP winning 2 Super Bowl appearances Brett Favre?

    A bit different.


    That meme- no idea when it was created, but it says "since Luck's rookie year". So if you're just looking at career ints, that doesn't work.
  7. 10ACTyrant

    10ACTyrant Starter

    3,151
    404
    109
    No, I'm taking a calculator and simply adding INTs since the 2012 season. Luck still has more, but only 8 more. Meanwhile, he has 40 more touchdowns in the same span.

    And yeah, I brought up Favre because it seems your entire argument revolves around interceptions. I have no idea what else it would be based on. Let's delve into that comparison a little more. In his first five seasons as a starter Favre threw 77 INTs to 147 TDs. Luck threw 68 INTs to 132 TDs. Luck started 7 fewer games in those five seasons though.

    I'm not saying Luck is the best QB in the league, but it's insane to act like he's garbage. He is the Colts.
    MariGOATa high fives this.
  8. Deuce Wayne

    Deuce Wayne Damnit, I cant find my driving moccasins anywhere!

    32,485
    7,375
    1,259
    What else it'd be based on? Mediocrity outside of throwing a lot.

    And he's not garbage. He's an average QB.
  9. MariGOATa

    MariGOATa Starter

    1,385
    276
    164

    And this is where this argument ends. When you had a Trent Richardson, and a past his prime Frank Gore, of course youd pass alot.. just gets to show you of how good Luck has been with a franchise thats been garbage in even sorrounding him with talent. Not sure if any of the young QBs could of done more than he has done for that franchise.

    I get it, the Colts are medias darling and were enemies against them, but you cant hate on a special talent like Luck.
  10. Wraith

    Wraith Starter

    596
    105
    169
    Luck is a marginally better version of Locker, but they are the same type/style of QB when you get down to it.
    Thaddeus43 high fives this.