Do you guys want Culpepper?

I'd have voted no, I dont agree with either of the choices. He's worth a second, just not for us. And I dont really want Brees either.

 

I just don't feel comfortable giving up a 2nd rounder for Culpepper. I mean the guy tore everything in his knee you can think of. If the injury would not have happened I would be all for it but all things the same I'm just not sold.

 

I'm with nigel here. I don't want either of them.

 

before thes debacle over his status in the last couple weeks i'd have said hell yes. his attitude and immaturity have made me far less enthusiastic.

 

it's also made him more affordable

 

It's still a no.

 

I think it would be great for him to join the Titans. He would fit right in.

 

I'm sorry I don't want him nor Brees I would rather develope Leinart or Young or Cutler(God Forbid) for the future of our QB spot

 

Culpepper's skills are similar to McNair's...in fact, he's probably better than McNair at throwing the deep ball. But Culpepper has never been the clutch performer that Mac is. Given the tools to work with, Mac is as good a clutch player as any I've ever seen. (Okay, maybe not the best...but he's definitely in the top two or three of the last 20 years.) And maybe I've gotten spoiled, but that means more to me than any measurables or stats.