E. Manning vs. V. Young

a couple of weeks ago when the Titans beat the Giants I posted that I'd take Eli over Vince straight up. Currently, almost at the half, Eli is 15/21, 175 yd, 2 td. That's outstanding. That kind of pass production is what I want to see. Is today the day Vince lights it up? Would our coaches play Eli the same way they play Vince? Is Vince underutilized? Who do you like?

public poll attached.

When's the last time our QB had 21 passing attempts in the first half?

for real. McNair would routinely would he not? Doesn't that kind of destroy the Fisher won't have Dinger call pass argument? Could the play selection be a product of player abilities?

Vy should have 38 passes today, IF Fisher is serious about winning.

I don't know when but i can almost guarantee it was a game we lost.

I have to say that Eli has better weapons...

S. Smith, Manningham and Nicks are great WR's.

Washington, Gage and Britt are alright (Britt has major potential).

Even though we have CJ, I'm going to have to say that Ahmad Bradshaw and Brandon Jacobs beat CJ/Ringer.

Eli in a heartbeat.

He's a Super Bowl winning QB. 'Nuff said.

Well we all know this.. if Vince passes well it's because of Fisher's awesome gameplan, and if throws poorly it's all because Vince sucks.

(fwiw I voted Eli, in a heartbeat is stronger than I feel but gotta work with the options you get)

Vince was definitely made to look bad vs the Steelers. Overall though he's shown me enough since his return last season that he can throw well when asked to do.

Those two hail marys last week were both great throws. Had one of them been caught the media would be singing Vince praises all week.

Manning plays very well when he gets protection but makes bad decisions under pressure.

Eli still makes retarded decisions..and more frequently than VY. Either way it doesn't matter, our offensive philosophy would not be any different and overall success would be the same more than likely.