E. Manning vs. V. Young

Eli has now looked like JaMarcus Russell since this thread was made... 2/9, 2 INTs and the Giants are well on their way to matching the '06 meltdown vs the Titans.

 

KC can make all the throws that Eli can yet our offense was stil run first. With Fisher coaching, it doesn't matter what type of QB you have. He won't light you up with stats very often. I like VY if he continue to improve because of his mobility and how he compliments CJ perfectly. But i do like ELI

 

The only reason the Giants won that SB was because of a bonehead decision made by Eli. If that pass wasn't miraculously caught by Tyree, that was the dumbest pass option on the field probably.