Future QB

It IS 28!

Carr is 29.

Yep its official. I'm an idiot, but that's okay. As long as I'm not a big idiot.

 

Yea and?

It's not like Collins ever developed into an awesome playmaker like we thought Young would do. If I use my #3 overall pick on a QB he damn well better be a great QB. Thus far Young is worth about a 3rd round pick. Yea I mean he deserves at least another year but if it's more of the same then I'm sorry. To me Mark Sanchez looks too good to pass up in 2010.

 

WOW, so I Gguess kerry is the reason the Titans are in the playoffs right? Geez, i thought it was chris johnson adding running pressure with some great schemes from heimerdinger. But of course not. Kerry is the teams savior right? So if Vince was QB we prob would have gone 0-16. Im just trying to understand what the numbers are saying that means vince young is a terrible quaterback. I guess two back 2 back winning seasons arent enough right.

 

Dude.

Vince was wildly inconsistent in 07. He had more stinkers than good games & his turnovers were killing us.We were winning in spite of him at times rather than because of him.

He had the hamstring injury through no fault of his own & without his mobility he was bad.He played maybe two really good games.Most of the time he was asked to throw it I had to take immodium just to stay safe.

 

Given that we were 13-2 going into the last meaningless game nobody can claim that one player got us to that point. There are many but in my opinion collins has been our most valuable player because he rarely got sacked, rarely turned the ball over and managed an 80 passing rating despite having the worst Wrs in the league.

Collins was available every play not 55% of the plays like haynesworth. He made it possible for us to win almost every game and played his best in games that we needed it the most. Bears, jags, steelers.

 

Collins has won 4-5 games alone this season. CJ is good but without the threat of Collins teams would commit to shutting down CJ. Collins arm has opened up our running game. you put VY back in there and no team is going to worry about the pass they will be stopping CJ and VY from running. And we would be lucky to win 9 games.

 

I feel CJ has been more valuable than Kerry adding a dynamic to the offense, although CJ would not be able to do what he's done without Kerry being a consistent passing threat that avoids the blow-up game-changing mistakes (fumbles, int's).

Rolltide is right, he is valuable in that keeping the mistakes at a minimum is what keeps this team ticking. Kerry had 1 fumble this year, Vince had 10 last year. Imagine if we had 1 more fumble, and 1 more INT in EVERY game we played this year. Hard to keep a #1 AFC seed with mistakes piling up like that regularly. Not just on the immediate effect, but errors take away momentum from an in-game and game-to-game basis too.

 

I disagree seeing how he played in his first game