McNair didn't have any better of a season than a rookie, Vince Young. He did absolutely nothing in baltimore, and everyone overlooked it while the defense was scoring all the points. Then in the playoffs it was nationally televised, and everyone saw what he'd been doing all season. Nothing. Riding the success of the D. He was robbed 2 times back in the day, I agree with that, but McNair is an average Qb in the afc. Plenty guys that have an argument to go if he has one.