Volek wasn't a scrub but you're overrating him like crazy. Did you actually watch the games that season or just looked at the boxscore? By the time Volek replaced McNair, our season was a lost cause already so Volek got the green light to freelance and that drastically padded his numbers (or maybe you already knew Volek wasn't that good and buttering him up was just an excuse to hate on McNair, see last paragraph for what I mean). And you act like Volek had a pro bowl year or something, he had two monster games that helped him have a decent overall season, but he is what he is, a career back up. There's a reason why we traded him for a bag of chips and to a team that already had a franchise QB. If he was anywhere near as good as you make him out to be, he would have gotten a shot somewhere. It's ironic that you call out people for overrating McNair because he's dead when you like to criticize him for the very same reason. I can bet if McNair was alive, you wouldn't criticize him nearly as much and that's because you say things for shock value, to get a reaction, because you know a lot of people are sensitive when it comes to McNair.