The official Corey Dillion or Michael Turner thread..

Dillion.

I dont get why you would draft a running back with your 2nd overall pick the year before then bring in a new guy to start over him.

LenDale is our guy not Turner.

 

Neither. I'd take Brown over both.

 

Dillon

Because I think they could give up too much for Turner.

Advantage - Getting Turner would make us set at RB for the next 5+ years.

Disadvantage - Swapping 1st rd picks and giving up a 2nd or 3rd, and maybe a 2nd or 3rd next year is just too much. Don't be like houston and give up too much for a back up player.

By me saying this now, the Titans will probably go ahead and make the trade.

 

Ill take White, and if I must go this far, Id take Jarrett Payton

 

As much as I've rooted for Brown to succeed,we all know he just can't stay healthy. When in, he's pretty decent. Although, he did lose the starting nod to Henry last year...was it due to injury?

 

you're quickly losing credibility

 

Turner has too much upside. Swapping 1st's is worth it plus a 3rd. Getting a Turner caliber back for a 3rd pick and moving 11 spots down in the first where Jarrett will be anyway is not a bad deal. He isn't worth "giving" our 1st pick away. We may be able to pick up a quality DE.

 

Well I wouldn't want him as a feature back. But if he's either splitting carries with LenDale or primarily handling just the 3rd down back duties, I'm a lot less concerned about his durability.

 

Payton was a good goal line back for us a couple of years ago. He could get the tough yard. That's pretty much it though.