S. McNair and M. Vick are having great years right and V Young is the struggling rookie right. Well that's what the national media would pitch you but look at the number straight from the offical NFL stats QB rating-(that number that only NASA understands) Vick 66.0, McNair 64.1, V. Young 56.5-none are at the top of the leauge but it is closer than you would think TD's and interceptions-Vick has 3td's-3int, McNair has 5td's-7int, V. Young has 3td's-4int. again none are at the top but not much difference is there. Completion %-Vick 50.4, McNair 56.2, V. Young 47.5 again none are tearing up the leauge. Vick and McNari are being touted as saviors for thier teams while V. Young is still learning. Looks pretty similar to me.