Williams v McCaffrey - Draft Wars Rd. 1

Maybe giving McCaffrey a look isn't such a horrible idea after all?

Derrick Henry's absence on first day of offseason work creates bad optics

Doh!

 

I voted McCaffrey, Mike Williams screams bust to me (or just mediocre career).

McCaffrey could start out as a guy you can line up anywhere, especially on 3rd downs, and then after Murray is done we can have a nice combo with him and Henry.

 

I don't really want a McCaffery pick, because I think other players will better suit our needs.

But I wouldn't hate it. And I would much prefer it to a Williams pick. I just don't see anything special there. I don't even like him as much as I liked Justin hunter or DGB.

I will say McCaffery is a very safe pick. Team guy. Professional. I could see jrob getting wood for a guy like that, and if he's around at 18, pulling the trigger.

 

At 18 I'm more than good with McCaffrey but I doubt he's there. I don't want Mike Williams at 5 (prefer defense) but I think he's gonna be good, his attitude,physicality and hunger for the rock remind me of Dez. He showed toughness and big heart coming back from neck injury and in that championship game.

 

Williams is my 2nd fav. WR after Corey Davis. But I don't want either at #5. I wouldn't want McCaffery at #18 unless there really wasn't another option. With all of the QBs, O-line, and RBs that should go before pick 18, that should push some good players down to us.