‘Steve McNair: A Football Life’ airs Wednesday

CJ had 2 great years then fell off a cliff

Eddie was the gold standard of the NFL for nearly a decade

 

Anyone that thinks otherwise is either
1. Didn't watch Eddie and not a Titans fan
B. Is a tool

 

I think that you nailed the issue. Considering MariGOATa's age, it's not likely that he has seen much of Eddie playing in his prime.

 

Eddie was a beast and carried this team with his mentality, desire and toughness.

Ask Ray Lewis

 

Ask Ray Lewis which one was the better RB, he's defended against them both.

Given what Ray Ray has said recently about Eddie, I'm pretty sure what his answer would be.

 

Lol, I was just typing the same thing!

 

Wow he stiff armed Ray Lewis. What a beast! I guess one highlight reel against a HoF makes you automatically the best. My bad.

CJ > eg

 

You're certainly entitled to your opinion. I'm pretty sure that you're going to find that it's going to be in the minority though.

 

I’m fine with that. CJ was a rare talent across the NFL. Considering both of the players and their talents around, Eddie had a much much better supporting cast. Eddie never even averaged 4 ypc for his career.

 

I'm not knocking CJ, he arguably had the best single season of any player during the Titans era.

They had complely different playing styles, though. Opponents would stack the box KNOWING Eddie was coming and still couldn't stop him. He made defenders pay on every carry.