Discussion in 'Tennessee Titans and NFL Talk' started by xpmar9x, Dec 23, 2010.
how about "would you smoke VY's pole" poll?
I'll take the proverbial flier on both
I'd give up VY and Finnegan for Rodgers.
Does it really matter who we have as long as JF is the coach?
Fisher may be a problem but he's not the reason VY isn't what he was drafted to be.
I'd take VY. Rogers can't win the big game. He's also played with much, much better receivers than Vince.
I wish people would atleast give an explanation as to why they'd choose either QB instead of just saying "it's obvious"...why because ESPN says so?
Vince has a much higher upside than Rogers. Rogers has hit his ceiling. He won't get much better than he is now.
Vince on the other hand is still improving and threw what...3 picks this season? One of those came in a last minute hail mary. Rogers is a good QB but not great. Vince has the potential to be great.
A pure pocket passer won't get us anywhere with out skill set. CJ won't benefit from a pocket passer.
I'm ready to see Vince with a different playbook and all his weapons on the field. How many times has Rogers taken over a game or led a comeback??
Are you saying Vince Young has played poorly? Is that what your saying? Because if you want to compare stats...
Are you saying Rogers is anywhere close to Brady?? Because that would be a joke. Brady isn't in the poll
I was responding to the thread in general. Not your post. Should've made that clear.
Rodgers is 10x better than VY.
Probably just a poll to bring back the Vince hate, I suppose.
Separate names with a comma.