Comeback Player of the Year: Manning or Peterson?

AP is in total beast mode right now.

And he's not fumbling

Should be Peterson....will be Manning.

Peyton Manning actually missed last season, and is on a major comeback.

Adrian Peterson as dominating as he is, isn't coming back from 4 neck surgeries. Plus he played last year, what's he coming back from, he kinda never was gone, he scored 13 TD's last year right? His recovery has been nothing short of stellar, but again, he played in 2011, Peyton didn't.

cant go wrong with either. But to think the Greatest QB ever was dumped by his team after multiple neck surgeries that was supposed to never let him play football again and is lighting it up in Denver after not playing for over a year? That's pretty special.

Not taking anything away from AP, I love his drive and Walter Payton-esque style. Especially watching Britt, AP looks that much better, but that's more on Britt than on AP. He's just a stud and carries that football team. He is a true PLAYMAKER!!

I vote Chad Pennington

I vote Peterson as runner-up, nothing wrong with that.

Peterson tore his ACL during last season and wasn't even projected to be back week 1 let alone start and now he has a shot at the single season rushing record. He gets my vote.

Peterson is a RB who tore his ACL, came back super early, and is better than before. It's not even close in my opinion, AD.

Thats a compelling argument.

AP best season by a RB ever ---------- PM best season of his career

Hmmm

Well for one, AP needs 506 yards to do that, and only has 3 games, IDK if he's going to average 169 a week. So he probably wont end up with most rushing yards in a year. PM will surpass his career best in a lot of things except TD's.