Who would you take? Personally, I'm not crazy about Luck. Seen a lot of prospects like him. I like what I see in RG3 a lot. Don't get me wrong, these guys are head over heels better than the QB class from last year. Personal preference, RG3.
Luck. In the end, head is the most important thing a QB has. Luck was superlative for more than one year on a not very talented team. And I don't know that I agree that these two are worse than the top two from last year. Newton and Locker Luck and RG3 Its closer than the media would have you believe. And quite frankly, If I had to pick one of the four, its the one we already have.
Definitely closer than what the media will say, but I really think all four QBs are going to be great in this league.
I feel bad for Luck the Colts in my opinion have set him up to fail in the league, your only weapons are Austin Collie and Reggie Wayne. You have a decent offensive line, and poor play at runningback.
Luck reminds of a more athletic Matt Ryan. But very smart in the pocket, can make all the throws, not elite but def a Top-10 QB. RG3 is something we've never seen before. He's got the Vick speed with a 10x better arm. RG3 could be an elite QB. My pref is RG3. He could be the next elite QB, or a huge bust. Luck will be solid, but not sure he'll ever be a "top 3" QB.
RG3 Luck has too much pressure on him, in my opinion. He's got a big forehead, err, shoes to fill in Indianapolis. On top of what everyone else has said that he has no real supporting cast. The fans will give him one season to settle in, and if by year two he isn't a superstar, I envision they will be clamoring for his replacement. But all this talk of quarterbacks makes me want to see what Locker is really made of. I don't think he will be the next Brady or Manning but I could see him being the next Rodgers.