At the same time if Steve McNair was in this draft based on the comments made you wouldn't take him either. I really don't think Rolltide is arguing if Tebow is better or not but the point is if Tebow was a viable pick or better yet can a guy like him be a viable pick. Also Newton isn't Tebow. Tebow is slower and doesn't have a very good arm. What success Tebow has had certainly doesn't make the argument for not taking Newton and if anything makes the argument to take him. Tebow wasn't bad his first few starts. He was effective with his legs. He didn't sit for three years.